Abstract: Smartwatches such as the Apple Watch collect vast amounts of intimate health and fitness data as we wear them. Users have little choice regarding how this data is processed: The Apple Watch can only be used with Apple’s iPhones, using their software and their cloud services. We are the first to publicly reverse-engineer the watch’s wireless protocols, which led to discovering multiple security issues in Apple’s proprietary implementation. With WatchWitch, our custom Android reimplementation, we break out of Apple’s walled garden – demonstrating practical interoperability with enhanced privacy controls and data autonomy. We thus pave the way for more consumer choice in the smartwatch ecosystem, offering users more control over their devices.